"Do or Do not. There is no try."

“Ben Carson Is In Danger Of Losing All Respect”: He Can Only Lose In This Campaign, And More Than Just The Republican Primary

Over decades of a brilliant career as a brain surgeon, Dr. Ben Carson attracted legions of admirers — black, white and brown; liberal, moderate and conservative; fundamentalist Christian and agnostic. His story is the stuff of legend, the awe-inspiring tale of a poor black boy in Detroit who overcame daunting obstacles and vaulted to the very top of his profession.

Given that his profession was pediatric neurosurgery, black Americans were particularly proud. Carson, who was the first surgeon to successfully separate conjoined twins attached at the head, stood as stark repudiation of invidious stereotypes about black intellectual capacity. His memoir, Gifted Hands, has been passed through countless black households.

But the good doctor’s foray into Republican presidential politics threatens to become his epitaph, to overshadow — perhaps even to overwhelm — his academic and surgical accomplishments. He will likely be remembered as the GOP’s latest black mascot, a court jester, a minstrel show. He’ll be the Herman Cain of 2016.

Clearly, Carson’s chances of winning the Republican nomination for president stand at less than zero. No matter how many cheers he attracts at conservative gabfests, no matter how many of his bumperstickers appear on the vehicles of true believers, no matter how many Fox News pundits suggest he’s a viable candidate, he won’t come close to becoming the GOP standard bearer.

Nor should he. He is dangerously unqualified for the presidency — a political novice who is happily ignorant of policy, both foreign and domestic, and contemptuous of religious pluralism and personal liberties.

Carson catapulted to stardom in the ultraconservative firmament in 2013, when he addressed the National Prayer Breakfast with a speech in which he lashed out at the Affordable Care Act as President Obama sat nearby. Though the breakfast has a long history of nonpartisanship, Carson chose to criticize many of the policies that the president supports, including progressive taxation.

That was enough to cause conservatives to swoon. Since Obama’s election, Republicans have been sensitive to charges that their small tent of aging voters has become a bastion of white resentment, a cauldron of bigotry, nativism and fear of the other. They want to show that their fierce resistance to all things Obama has nothing to do with race.

That promotes a special affection for black conservatives who are willing to viciously criticize the president. As with Cain before him, Carson garners the most enthusiastic cheers from conservative audiences when he’s excoriating Obama, the most rapturous applause when he seems to absolve them of charges of bigotry. Why would Carson trade on his reputation to become their token?

I’ve little doubt that his conservative impulses are genuine. He grew up Seventh-Day Adventist, a conservative religious tradition. Moreover, he has adopted a view popular among white conservatives: that black Democrats give short shrift to traditional values such as thrift, hard work and sacrifice. (Hasn’t Carson ever heard any of Obama’s riffs excoriating deadbeat dads and promoting discipline, scholarship and parental involvement in their children’s lives?)

But Carson hardly represents the long and honorable tradition of black conservatism in America. Starting with the father of that movement, Booker T. Washington, its adherents have had a healthy appreciation for the reality of racism in America. Carson, however, thinks Obamacare “really (is) the worst thing that has happened in this nation since slavery. And … it is slavery in a way.” Washington and his peers, who knew better, would never have countenanced such nonsense.

Moreover, black conservatism has promoted self-reliance, but it hasn’t been a font of right-wing intolerance and know-nothingism. Carson, for his part, has dismissed evolution (giving his former colleagues at Johns Hopkins heartburn); he has compared homosexuality to bestiality; and he has spurned the First Amendment’s separation of church and state.

Given the ultraconservative politics of GOP primary voters, those extreme positions may help Carson in the early campaign season. But those views also guarantee that mainstream Republican leaders and their donors will flock elsewhere, seeking to find an experienced, broadly appealing and electable candidate.

Carson can only lose in this campaign — and more than just the Republican primary. He also stands to lose his place as one of the nation’s most admired men.


By: Cynthia Tucker, a Pulitzer Prize Winner for Commentary in 2007; The National Memo, May 9, 2015

May 10, 2015 - Posted by | Ben Carson, Conservatives, GOP Presidential Candidates | , , , , , , ,


  1. Actually, while imperfect and complex, Obamacare is working pretty well and the threat of business suffering is not supported on a larger scale. This is borne out by a number of surveys from the Kaiser Family Foundation which indicate it has greatly reduced the number of insureds and dampened cost increases. On this latter point, the Congressional Budget Office has lower healthcare cost projections three times in part due to Obamacare. Plus, PricewaterhouseCoopers has noted how overall premium increases have fallen. And, while survey results show Americans less supportive of the whole, when the component parts are surveyed, outside of the mandate, they poll very favorably. This all without fully implementing it in about 20 some odd states, who did not expand Medicaid. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, The Commonwealth Fund, the RAND Corporation, the Economic Policy Institute, Doctors for America and George Mason University, expanding Medicaid would help those in need, help the rural hospitals and help the economies in those states. George Mason even noted in their study, the Medicaid expansion would add jobs.

    The downside is Obamacare is complex, but that is in part due to the nature of the beast. It also has been poorly communicated, so many who are against it take advantage to misinform what it is and isn’t. This has harmed many people who elected not to be covered because people told them Obamacare was like slavery, Apartheid, and Nazism. When people resort to this kind of labeling, this means their argument is usually poor and that would include Dr. Ben Carson’s. Unfortunately, people believe this and elect not to be covered until it is too late.

    It does need some improvement – I would move the hours worked to above 32 or 36 hours, e.g., but doing away with it, is not supported by surveys of Americans, who only want it improved. And, the irony of all ironies, is Obamacare borrows heavily from a Republican idea in Romneycare which was supported by The Tea Party leadership for America until Obamacare was passed and the Romney ran for President. Please feel free to Google Jim DeMint and Romneycare to verify this statement.


    Comment by btg5885 | May 16, 2015 | Reply

    • There is a typo in the second sentence above. It should say “uninsureds.” Is it possible for you to make that edit? Sorry for my sloppiness. Many thanks, BTG


      Comment by btg5885 | May 16, 2015 | Reply

  2. To be frank, it perturbs me when a person of obvious intellect, waters it down to play to a base level of support. We have had numerous examples like Carson, when medical doctors betrayed their training to say inane things, even medical things. Carson’s comments about gays in prison, supporting the rights over a gun owner over people who died on his table as a result of gun wounds or equating Obamacare with slavery are just a few examples. When someone resorts to labels, then that shows their arguments are poor. Obamacare is working pretty well, but is not perfect. but slavery? Really? Santorum has called it akin to Apartheid and others have called it Nazism. Really?


    Comment by btg5885 | May 10, 2015 | Reply

    • the law is not working! rates are higher and business suffers! I thought you wanted jobs this law is destroying them! she has insulted a great man! someone who she is small in comparison!


      Comment by Ronald DeLong | May 15, 2015 | Reply

      • Apparently, you have not been paying attention!!


        Comment by raemd95 | May 15, 2015

Share your comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: