“An Assault On Collective Bargaining”: The Common Thread Of Supreme Court Decisions, “You’re On Your Own”
Although the Supreme Court’s decision in the Hobby Lobby case is getting most of the attention today, the other major case the justices decided, regarding public-sector unions, could prove to be even more significant. And in both cases, the court had a common message: You’re on your own.
That may not be how the union decision, Harris v. Quinn, looks on first glance. Indeed, the conservative majority cast it as a conflict between the freedom of individual workers and the interests of a union, and they sided with the workers. But make no mistake: This case is one part of a larger assault on collective bargaining, and the majority even hinted in its decision that there would be more to come. So often, cases such as these come down to questions of power: who has it, who doesn’t and on whose behalf should it be exercised. And this court’s majority knows where power belongs.
Harris v. Quinn was a case about whether home health-care workers in Illinois, who are paid by Medicaid, would have to pay some dues to the union that negotiates salaries and benefits on their behalf even if they choose not to join. If they were allowed to become free riders, getting the benefits of union representation without paying for it, the union’s position becomes far less sustainable. But the court held that the workers’ free speech rights were violated by the requirement, since the union might say things with their money that they disagreed with (though none of those dues go to political activity, and they aren’t required to actually join the union if they don’t wish to). The court said that it could strike down the law because these workers aren’t state employees even though they’re paid by Medicaid; it also described the 1977 case that allowed the requirement on state employees as having “questionable foundations,” a signal that the court may be gearing up to overturn that case and deal a fatal blow to all public-sector unions.
It’s no coincidence that the public sector is the core of what remains of union power in the United States today. And taken together, today’s two decisions mark yet another step in a direction this court has long been moving: toward more power in corporate hands, and less for ordinary people.
One does begin to wonder where the court sees any limits on corporate power at all. In Citizens United, the court ruled that corporations have free speech rights that enable them to spend all they want to influence the political process. In Hobby Lobby, the court ruled that corporations have religious rights that trump the rights of their employees and allow the corporation to pick which laws it would like to follow and which it would like to ignore. The decision extends the corporation’s control over its employees’ lives beyond what happens when they’re working, beyond even things they do that could affect their work, to a purely private arena that touches on their employment only because that’s where they’re getting their health insurance.
And as Harris v. Quinn shows, the court’s conservatives become concerned about workers and their rights only when some subset of workers is seeking to undermine unions, which exist to equalize the power imbalance between employers and employees.
In other words, both these cases are about power, and this Supreme Court is determined that it be moved more and more into the hands of those who already have it. And you can bet there’s more to come.
By: Paul Waldman, The Plum Line, The Washington Post, June 30, 2014
Related
July 7, 2014 - Posted by raemd95 | Collective Bargaining, Public Sector Unions, Supreme Court | Citizens United, Conservatives, Corporations, Harris v Quinn, Hobby Lobby, Workers
No comments yet.
Pages
Share This Blog
mykeystrokes.com
- “The Unrelenting Hostility Of Washington’s Courtier Press”: The Media’s Crusade Of Scandals Against Hillary Clinton July 28, 2016
- “Endorsing This Philistine”: The Christian Right Has Surrendered To Trump July 24, 2016
- “Cop Killers Serve No Cause”: It’s Getting To The Point Where No Lives Matter July 24, 2016
Top Posts
- "You Work For Us Now": Could The Koch Brothers Swallow Up The GOP?
- "Endorsing This Philistine": The Christian Right Has Surrendered To Trump
- "An Ethical Philistine": Why Trump Leads Among Evangelical Voters — Even Though He’s A Religious Illiterate
- "Cruz, Trump Pray Each Other Away In SC": There Isn’t A Whole Lot Of Love-Thy-Neighbor Going On
- "The G.O.P.’s Holy War": Righteousness Is A Tricky Business, It Has A Way Of Coming Back To Bite You
- "Unwrapping Falwell’s Trump Endorsement": Trump "Reminds Me So Much Of My Father"
-
Affordable Care Act African Americans Bain Capital Citizens United Congress Conservatives Contraception Corporations Debt Ceiling Democracy Democrats Donald Trump Economic inequality Economy Foreign Policy Fox News George W. Bush GOP GOP Presidential Candidates Government Shutdown Gun Control Gun Violence Health Exchanges Health Insurance Hillary Clinton House Republicans Immigration Immigration Reform Iraq War ISIS Jeb Bush Jobs John Boehner John McCain Koch Brothers Lindsey Graham Marco Rubio media Medicaid Medicare Middle Class Middle East Minorities Mitch McConnell Mitt Romney National Security Newt Gingrich NRA ObamaCare Paul Ryan Politics Poor and Low Income Poverty Progressives Racism Rand Paul Republicans Rick Santorum Right Wing Ronald Reagan Rush Limbaugh Scott Walker SCOTUS Senate Spending Cuts Tax cuts Taxes Tea-party Teaparty Ted Cruz Terrorism uninsured Voter Suppression Wall Street Wealthy
Categories
Archives
Blogroll
Twitter Timeline
- RT @brianschatz: McConnell is threatening to filibuster the Organizing Resolution which allows Democrats to assume the committee Chair posi…----------- 8 hours ago
- RT @BidenInaugural: Tune in TONIGHT at 8:30pm ET for our Celebrating America event! You won't want to miss this lineup:----------- 1 day ago
- RT @skip_conover: If you’re watching #fox instead of CNN or #MSNBC you’re missing the music and the party!----------- 1 day ago
- RT @matthewamiller: We made it, everyone. God Bless America.----------- 1 day ago
- That's my daughter. Proud Dad!! twitter.com/HustleFundBaby…----------- 1 day ago
Blog Stats
- 265,942 hits
Share your comment