"Do or Do not. There is no try."

The Minnesota Shutdown – A Glimpse Into The Nation’s Future And The GOP’s True Intentions

A telephone help line service for the elderly will not be ringing today in Minnesota.

Blind residents reliant on state funding for reading services will remain in the dark for as long as the government’s lights are turned off. Poor families who receive subsidies for childcare are on their own. The St. Louis Park Emergency Program’s food shelf will have bare pickings for those who depend on the program for sustenance. The Community

Action Center of Northfield will likely be forced to close down its homeless shelter without the state funding upon which it relies to house the homeless.

And yes, 23,000 state workers will be trying to figure out how to care for their families without a paycheck for the duration along with an estimated 5,000 to 10,000 construction workers who will be laid off as the state shuts down dozens of road and highway projects.

These are but a few of the consequences of the shutdown of Minnesota’s government.

At issue is how to close a $5 billion deficit in the state left by the previous Minnesota governor, Tim Pawlenty.

Minnesota Governor Mark Dayton, a Democrat, had tried to bargain his way toward an agreement by offering up massive cuts in state services. In return, he asked the Republicans to agree to a tax increase for the wealthier citizens of the state to make up the remainder of the funding required to close most of the gap in the budget.

But the Republicans held firm on taxes – even when Dayton made his final offer that would have placed an additional 3% tax on only those Minnesotans earning over $1 million a year, a burden that would have been placed on just .03% of all Minnesotans.

It’s not so much that the state’s GOP leaders had a violent, allergic reaction to those earning seven figures a year having to pay a few percentage points more in taxes. What appears to have ended negotiations were the

Republican demands that Governor Dayton agree to their social agenda issues, including Voter ID legislation and abortion restrictions, as the price for the Republicans allowing the very wealthy to pay a little more.

When the Governor refused to swallow the notion that the conservative social agenda should be used as a tool to resolve budgetary issues, the talks broke down and the lights at the statehouse were turned off.

So, you might wonder, how did the Minnesota GOP suggest that the gap in the finances be met even as they seemed to realize that there was little left for the Governor to offer on the cutting side of the ledger?

You won’t believe it.

The Republicans actually proposed creating more debt to close the gap.

The GOP proposed delaying another $700 million in payments owed to schools, which would add to the more than $1 billion the state already owes K-12 schools.

Republicans also offered to issue “tobacco bonds” of an unspecified amount to cover any remaining budget gap. Sources said Dayton considered the offer, but he criticized it as unwise borrowing late Thursday. Via The Star Tribune

I guess a Republican has to do what a Republican has to do when it comes to protecting the wealthiest in the state from paying a higher tax rate- even if it means creating more debt despite a GOP platform that, allegedly, abhors debt.

If you find the lessons of Minnesota disturbing, get used to it.

What you are seeing is simply the national debate playing out on a smaller stage. I suppose this is what Republicans mean when they suggest using the states as laboratories for what will and won’t work on the national level.

You can bet that every political player on the national stage will be watching to see how the Minnesota public reacts to their situation along with which party gets the lion’s share of the blame for bringing this blight upon their land.

If Governor Dayton caves and simply accepts the GOP budget, we can expect that our Congressional Republicans would take great heart in such an occurrence and be emboldened to stick with the plan.

If the GOP legislators begin to fear that their jobs may be in jeopardy as punishment for shutting down the state in order to protect a little more than 7,000 Minnesotans earning at least a million bucks a year, that too will be noticed.

Watch the polls in Minnesota over the next week or two. They may tell you everything you need to know about what is likely to happen as we move towards resolving the debt ceiling debate.


By: Rick Ungar, The Policy Page, Forbes, Junly 1, 2011

July 3, 2011 - Posted by | Class Warfare, Conservatives, Deficits, Democracy, Economy, GOP, Government, Government Shut Down, Governors, Ideologues, Ideology, Lawmakers, Middle Class, Politics, Public, Public Employees, Republicans, Right Wing, Seniors, State Legislatures, States, Union Busting, Unions, Wealthy | , , , , , , , , ,

1 Comment »

  1. Richard, Mr. Ungar’s analysis is spot on. Thank you for bringing his work to our attention.

    We have been having this discussion for months it seems, and Mr. Ungar focuses the issues very well. At the core of the Republican position is the destruction of government so that the corporations can have unfettered access to natural resources, labor, and capital with minimal intervention or oversight. One may think that the goal is the overarching social agenda of the Christian far-right, but in my opinion they are simply a tactical weapon being used to put moderate politicians in untenable positions at the bargaining table.

    I may be wrong, but it seems that the goal is an oligarchical control of our civilization. In a sense, it reminds me of the feudal European dark ages when control was local and protected by vassals and hired mercenaries. The peasants had no voice and belonged to the aristocracy. The corollaries are present to show this connection.

    The moneyed classes have a direct interest is seeing the corporate “persons” as defined by “Citizens United” use their power to control elections, reduce the franchise, and silence dissent. As the people are either lulled into complacency, manipulated into advocating for policies that are in opposition to their core “real” interest, or silenced by law, media poliicy, and intimidation, the government becomes a struggling dying beast.

    By depriving that beast of sustenance (revenues) and convincing the impressionable that the beast is evil, the rich and powerful can as Grover Norquist so eloquently stated, “I simply want to reduce it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub.”

    By depriving government of resources and popluar support the Nouveau GOP can drown it. The replacement I fear will be a collection of “pledge signers” and other individuals who have sworn oaths of fealty to their corporate and ideological heroes. Their motivation will be to please their masters, not the people. The people will be further cast into subjugation as their rights to form unions will be termed conspiracies. Living standards will diminish, fear will rise, and violence will increase.

    We can stop this madness. We must vet our politicians, vote, and then hold them accountable for doing the peoples business. We need a platform that will reduce the power of lobbyist. We need to win back a solid majority in the house, sixty seats in the senate and reelect President Barak Obama. Let me stress that as important as this is, it is equally important to act locally. Take back the governorships and state houses.

    To do this we must be vigilant and communicate in effective ways what’s really at stake. We need to win over some of the Tea Party who are emotionally reacting but being played by the GOP marionettes. We must convince the far left that to protect the freedoms we do hold dear, it is better to work through the ballot.


    Comment by mjg7 | July 3, 2011 | Reply

Share your comment

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: